Real measurements call for operational solutions: ISABELE, applied to the housing sector

Showing whether promises have been kept is the main goal of measuring a building's intrinsic energy performance, whether it is a new-build or renovation project. In 2017, the CSTB’s ISABELE (In-Situ Assessment of Building Envelope Performance) measurement method was transformed from an R&D protocol into a fully operational system, known as MERLiN, made available to the professional sector. It was developed by the CSTB, the CEREMA (Center for the Study and Expertise of Risks, the Environment, Mobility and Development) and COSTIC (Scientific and Technical Committee of Climatic Industries) as part of the PACTE program (Action Program for the Quality of Construction and the Energy Transition). Here is a close-up of how this program applies to the housing sector, and its prospects for the future.

It is crucial to offer a collaborative, reliable method to measure the energy performance of buildings in the field. MERLiN provides a concrete, operational solution on this topic. MERLiN is a comprehensive procedure based primarily on the ISABELE measurement method of the CSTB, focused building envelopes. It provides a snapshot of a building’s energy characteristics at the time of commissioning, providing proof that the performance targets have been met. It also makes it possible to begin the building’s operational phase under optimal conditions.

The operational protocol of the ISABELE method was developed in collaboration with the construction industry. This also provided an opportunity to prepare for the transfer of knowledge to the market, well upstream in the process. In 2017, dedicated working groups in Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur and Brittany brought together project owners, consulting firms, measurement operators and professional representatives. They guided the development and validation of the method in the field. In parallel, ISABELE completed its “Tour de France,” during which it was deployed at several worksites. ISABELE is now ready to be applied to individual housing units.

In 2018, as part of the MERLiN project, R&D continued on the reproducibility of the ISABELE method in apartment and office buildings. The CSTB is also working to adapt the ISABELE protocol to meet the special requirements of renovation projects. The first experiments are being conducted in 2018 in close collaboration with the city of Grenoble, an R&D partner of the CSTB for the energy efficiency of residential buildings. partenaire R&D du CSTB au service de l’efficacité énergétique du parc résidentiel.

The MERLiN procedure (In-Situ Measurement of the Intrinsic Energy Performance of Housing at Commissioning) measures the intrinsic energy performance of housing units on completion of construction projects. It offers quick, simple instruments at controlled costs, to measure the actual energy performance of the building envelope and to check if the systems of ventilation, heating and domestic hot water production are operating properly. The innovative ISABELE method, developed by the CSTB, is one of the key components of the MERLiN system. In addition to the existing measurement of air tightness, it also measures the building envelope’s overall thermal insulation level at the time of commissioning.

Anne-Sophie Grave
CEO of 3F Group
“If construction costs are higher for more quality, we have to make sure that the results are real.”

“For us, it is a priority commitment to control energy-related costs for our housing tenants.

Of course, this depends on how occupants use the premises, as well as the quality of the construction. As a building stock manager involved in sustainable development and innovation, 3F Group wants to measure actual energy performance to optimize its projects. If construction costs are higher for more quality, we have to make sure that the results are real.

As part of our partnership, the CSTB deployed its ISABELE method at two private Normandy-style houses in our building stock. The in situ measurement of the actual thermal insulation product in the envelope of these new houses, on acceptance of the work, made it possible to identify inconsistency with theoretical calculations made by the consulting firm in the design phase. We are conducting analyses to identify the causes.

We also want to expand measurements to a broader sample of buildings by continuing testing with the ISABELE method on apartments. This will allow us to strengthen our procedures to provide good outcomes and services to occupants, while offering a varied and representative testing ground of the French housing stock for the CSTB.”

Find out more